Last week, among a flurry of Executive Orders issued by the White House, President Trump issued one aimed at eliminating what his administration views as dangerous and potentially discriminatory diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) practices. The order was issued in response his concerns that many American institutions, including federal agencies, corporations, and educational institutions, had adopted practices that may violate civil rights laws under the banner of DEI initiatives.
The order emphasizes that while discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin is prohibited, businesses should focus on promoting individual initiative, excellence, and hard work.
Consider a small tech company looking to hire software developers. Rather than setting specific diversity targets, the company would need to focus on creating opportunities based purely on merit and qualifications. This might involve partnering with various professional organizations and educational institutions to reach a broad talent pool, while ensuring that all hiring decisions are based strictly on candidates’ skills, experience, and potential – similar to how a sports coach would select players based solely on their abilities.
To maintain a diverse workforce while staying compliant with the new requirements, businesses should focus on expanding their recruitment reach while keeping evaluation processes strictly merit-based. This means advertising positions through various channels and professional networks, but ensuring that the selection process focuses exclusively on qualifications and capabilities. Job descriptions should emphasize required skills and experience rather than any demographic characteristics.
The Executive Order specifically prohibits programs that give preferences based on race, color, sex, or other protected characteristics. Companies must avoid any workforce balancing based on demographic characteristics and ensure their DEI programs don’t violate federal anti-discrimination laws. The order makes it clear that hiring and advancement should be based on individual achievement and merit rather than identity-based considerations.
Creating an inclusive workplace culture remains important, but it must be done through merit-based approaches. Companies can implement professional development opportunities and mentorship programs, but these must be open to all employees and based on skills and career goals rather than demographic factors.
The focus should be on creating an environment where every employee has an equal opportunity to succeed based on their capabilities and work ethic.
While focusing on individual merit and competencies is the goal and an American ideal, it is possible that the Executive Order could inhibit hiring managers from ensuring a fair opportunity for everyone, particularly if they are consistently choosing from the same pool. Typically hiring managers operate in circles of folks demographically similar to them. If the net they are casting is not sufficiently wide enough, then qualified and competent individuals may never get an opportunity to apply for a job or get interviewed for a job.
While DEI quota systems were inherently questionable, the goal of opening opportunities to a more diverse pool of talent is admirable and an honorable goal. Restricting DEI initiatives to promote merit-based opportunities may not be the answer. The answer is more likely found in expanding the pool.
Moving forward, the key for businesses is to maintain fair and open processes that allow all qualified individuals to compete on equal footing. This means implementing clear, objective criteria for hiring and promotion decisions, documenting the basis for these decisions, and ensuring that all employees have access to the same opportunities for growth and advancement. By focusing on merit, skills, and achievements rather than demographic targets, businesses can build strong, capable teams while staying within the bounds of the law.
The Law Office of Eric R. Brown 
Leave a comment